Top 10 Best Dessert Spots in St. Catharines, Ontario (2026)

Our community picks for the best ice cream, gelato, cakes and late-night desserts in St. Catharines, Ontario — independent, family-run and locally-loved places, ranked by rating and community feedback. Each spot links to its full profile with hours, menu highlights and vibe.

Dessert Spots in St. Catharines

  1. Happy Snack

    St. Catharines · 5/5 (108 reviews)

    When in St. Catharines and need a sweet pick-me-up, this bakery is your spot. Their pastries are simply divine and made with so much love!

    Known for: sweet pick-me-ups and divine pastries.

  2. Sugar + Butter Baking Co

    St. Catharines · 5/5 (67 reviews)

    For divine baked goods in St. Catharines, you have to try their cupcakes. A little slice of heaven!

    Known for: divine baked goods, especially their cupcakes.

  3. Johan Restaurant & Bakery

    St. Catharines · 4.9/5 (131 reviews)

    Johan Restaurant & Bakery offers a welcoming atmosphere in St. Catharines, serving a variety of baked goods alongside their restaurant fare. It's a convenient spot for a casual meal or to pick up fresh bread and…

    Known for: a variety of baked goods alongside restaurant fare.

  4. Budapest Bakeshop Port Dalhousie

    St. Catharines · 4.8/5 (183 reviews)

    Budapest Bakeshop offers a delightful selection of European-inspired pastries and baked goods in St. Catharines. This charming spot is perfect for enjoying a sweet treat with a warm drink. Whether you're grabbing a…

    Known for: Authentic Hungarian chimney cakes hand-rolled fresh daily in small batches

  5. The Keto Crumb.

    St. Catharines · 4.7/5 (186 reviews)

    The Keto Crumb is a St. Catharines bakery offering a selection of low-carbohydrate baked goods and treats. They focus on providing delicious options for those following a ketogenic lifestyle. Visit for a sweet…

    Known for: delicious low-carbohydrate baked goods and treats.

  6. Mitchell's Bakery and Marketplace

    St. Catharines · 4.6/5 (1105 reviews)

    Mitchell's Bakery and Marketplace offers a variety of freshly baked goods, from breads to pastries, made with attention to detail. Visitors can also find a selection of curated marketplace items to complement their…

    Known for: freshly baked goods and curated marketplace items

  7. St. Joseph Bakery

    St. Catharines · 4.6/5 (781 reviews)

    St. Joseph Bakery offers a selection of freshly baked goods, pastries, and breads. Located in St. Catharines, this spot provides a simple and satisfying experience for those seeking a sweet treat or a morning staple.…

    Known for: a selection of freshly baked goods, pastries, and breads

  8. The Frosted Cupcake

    St. Catharines · 4.5/5 (205 reviews)

    The Frosted Cupcake is a charming cafe located in St. Catharines, Ontario. This spot offers a delightful selection of sweet treats and beverages in a welcoming atmosphere. It's a pleasant place to visit for a casual…

    Known for: a delightful selection of sweet treats and beverages in a welcoming atmosphere

  9. Your Bakery

    St. Catharines · 4.5/5 (89 reviews)

    Your Bakery is a charming spot in St. Catharines, Ontario, offering a delightful array of freshly baked goods. From artisanal breads to delicate pastries, they craft each item with care. It's a lovely place to enjoy…

    Known for: a delightful array of freshly baked goods and warm drinks

  10. Origen Bistro | Bakery

    St. Catharines · 4.4/5 (168 reviews) · french

    Discover delicious flavors and delightful treats at Origen Bistro | Bakery in St. Catharines.

    Known for: delicious flavors and delightful treats from a bistro and bakery

Frequently asked questions

What are the best dessert spots in St. Catharines?

We rank the best ice cream, gelato, cakes and late-night desserts in St. Catharines by rating and community feedback, favouring independent and family-run spots — 10 are listed on this page.

Which dessert spots in St. Catharines are open late?

See our late-night guide at https://cupsandbites.com/st-catharines/open-late for spots in St. Catharines open past 10 p.m., with today's hours on every profile.

Can I book a table?

Spots that take reservations show a "Reserve a table" button on their profile; others show "Call to book" or are walk-in.

More in St. Catharines: Restaurants & Cafés in St. Catharines · Cafés in St. Catharines · Bars in St. Catharines · Pubs in St. Catharines · Brunch Spots in St. Catharines · Breakfast Spots in St. Catharines · Lunch Spots in St. Catharines · Dinner Restaurants in St. Catharines · Bakeries in St. Catharines · Coffee Shops in St. Catharines · Open late in St. Catharines